NY Proposals on HFC Phase-Out Stir Mixed Reactions

3 Min Read
"HFC Phase-Out"

The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) recently tabled proposals to phase out Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) as part of broader climate change mitigation strategies. While the rules aim to protect the environment, they could potentially increase heating costs in Buffalo, NY, stirring mixed reactions from residents.

Some laud the DEC’s environmental conservation efforts but are concerned about increased heating costs. To help those most affected, local authorities are exploring support mechanisms. The heating sector is also looking into alternative substances that could replace HFCs without significantly driving up consumer costs. Despite the short-term expenses, the transition could lead to long-term economic and environmental benefits.

The DEC’s proposals have sparked conversations about the balance of environmental demands with economic implications. While smaller businesses could struggle to bear the costs associated with the switch to eco-friendly alternatives, proponents argue that this venture could bolster energy efficiency, foster waste reduction, and stimulate new sectors of the economy.

However, a proposed law pushing for the complete phase-out of HFC refrigerants by 2034 has raised concerns within the business sector. The stringency and timing is perceived as infeasible both operationally and financially, raising concerns about potential disruptions and burdens, particularly for smaller businesses. The lack of certainty about the availability and effectiveness of alternative refrigerants compounds these fears.

Local business owner, Bob Mesmer, expresses the fears of many. He argues that the transition brings significant costs for upgrading systems, costs that might eventually be passed to consumers. Despite the environmental benefits, he warns of an increase in the price of goods and services, laying a burden on end consumers.

Conversations are ongoing as to how businesses can transition in a way that does not strain consumers or halt operations. There is increased interest in government policies or incentives that could ease the potential financial burdens. While the discourse is creating awareness of the need for change amongst local businesses, they still tread with caution.

Mesmer advocates for a balanced approach mirroring the federal approach of a gradual phase-out of HFCs. He encourages the DEC to consider the needs of businesses reliant on these substances to avoid potential disruptions and financial loss. His call is for dialogue with businesses to forge a comprehensive and implementable plan.

Officials insist that the new regulations are necessary to achieve emission targets, and public comment on the regulations has been extended until 5 p.m. on March 19. As the deadline nears, different stakeholders are submitting their views. The final ruling, expected to bear considerable economic and environmental implications, will be of keen interest to all.

Share This Article
Becca Williams is a writer, editor, and small business owner. She writes a column for and many more major media outlets.